Private Peaceful
Some stories live inside you long before the lights go down. Private Peaceful is one of those for me. I have a signed copy at home, and I know and love Michael Morpurgo’s novel incredibly well. Walking into Curve Studio, with First World War music playing and Tommo (Benjamin Cain) already asleep on stage, felt like stepping into something both familiar and fragile. The intimate space is perfectly suited to a memory play. From the first ticking of a watch, we move between Tommo’s uncertain present and the childhood memories that brought him there.
Morpurgo, perhaps best known for War Horse, often explores conflict through young eyes. Inspired by the histories of soldiers executed for cowardice during the First World War, Private Peaceful follows brothers Tommo and Charlie from rural childhood to the trenches. It is a story of love, loyalty, innocence and injustice, constructed around a devastating final revelation. Adapted for stage, and directed by Simon Reade, this production is courageous and often gripping, anchored by a performance of titanic stamina.

On stage, the entire “Peaceful” world rests on Benjamin Cain’s shoulders. Alone for eighty uninterrupted minutes, he conjures a family, a village and an army with little more than his voice and body. It is a formidable undertaking, and Cain is outstanding. Small shifts in stance, expression and tone create distinct personalities, often within seconds. Occasionally, the sheer number of characters makes it difficult to follow who is speaking, but Tommo remains crystal clear.
What impressed me most was the way Cain seems to age before our eyes. The early Tommo is open, eager, almost bouncing with a schoolboy’s excitement. Gradually his posture changes, his face hardens and his movements lose their youthful energy. We watch anger and disbelief grow as he discovers just how cruel the world can be. The transformation is subtle, convincing and increasingly moving. By the time he reaches the trenches, the boy we first met seems painfully distant.
One particularly haunting moment sees Tommo dressing for war while singing Oranges and Lemons unaccompanied. That familiar nursery rhyme, set against the act of putting on a uniform, is a stark reminder of the innocence of the boys sent to fight. With contemporary global tensions never far from our minds, the scene feels uncomfortably resonant.

The production’s restraint is its strength. The set (TPG) is simple, the lighting (Adam Foley) understated and the sound effects (Jason Barnes) sparing. The watch’s persistent ticking helps structure the shifts in time, but nothing competes with Morpurgo’s words or Cain’s storytelling. This is theatre reduced to its essentials, and it is thoroughly engrossing – this restraint keeps the storytelling front and centre.
My greatest reservation, however, is the ending. Without spoiling it, the adaptation changes the novel’s carefully prepared twist. I waited with bated breath for the revelation I knew, then found myself confused about which brother Cain was portraying. Once I realised what had changed, confusion gave way to disappointment. Charlie’s protective role is so important to the book that altering the conclusion weakened its emotional impact for me. I understand why a one-man production might place the final dramatic weight on Tommo, particularly when Charlie has less room to develop. But understanding a choice is not the same as being moved by it.

Even so, the Studio was full of young people, and it felt fitting that they were hearing this story of boys sent to war. Despite my disappointment at the end, this is incredible storytelling: energetic, disciplined and deeply human. I leave the Curve Studio with enormous admiration for Cain; this is a commanding performance that deserves to be seen.
Private Peaceful is playing at Leicester’s Curve Theatre until Thursday 19 November.

